Skip to main contentWebsite Accessibility Assistance

Cheers to Over 50 Years!

The Mad Italian has been making cheesesteaks and families happy for over 50 years. The purpose of The Mad Italian is to have a local place for friends and families to come, relax, have a drink, and enjoy a nice, affordable, traditional Italian meal. We want our customers to feel welcome from the moment they walk inthe door to the moment they leave the parking lot. We select the best quality ingredients, and cook our food with heart and passion in order to keep our customers satisfied and coming back for more! 
Fresh hoagie and sandwich rolls made in house at The Mad Italian

The Proper Roll

Months before The Mad Italian opened in 1973, the search had begun for the "Proper" Italian Roll. After sampling the bread of several local bakers, we presumed the physical conditions in this city prevented the production of a roll which met our standards. Because of water quality, humidity and altitude, Atlanta bread was just not light enough to suit us.

Soon after this discovery, Allied Bakers in Long Island assured us they could supply the roll we desired. The regular hoagie roll is baked by the Cassone Bakery of Port Chester, New York and weighs only 3.5 ounces. It is made with pure vegetable shortening. We believe this to be the " Proper" Italian Roll. We are sure you will agree.

The Mad Italian house made Italian dressing for retail sale

Our Dressing

We developed our Creamy Italian Dressing many years ago from our own ingredients. Through the years, it has certainly been our most popular. People use it as a salad dressing, a dip, a condiment for their hoagies or just eat it with a spoon! It is extremely rich and creamy, made with Italian spices and other fresh ingredients. We take alot of pride in our dressing and we will continue to make it in our own kitchen as long as we are in existence. Ask your server for the House Dressing and enjoy!

A vintage black-and-white photo of a restaurant building with signage reading "The Mad Italian." A classic car is parked nearby, with a striped awning visible on the left.

Homemade vs Hohum

For more than 40 years, The Mad Italian has strived to bring the freshest and best tasting food to your table. We offer the highest quality without regard to price and we take pride in what we serve.  We are convinced that our effort to make our own Meatballs, Sauces, Soups, Salad Dressings, Cheesecake Brownies and other items is what keeps our fans so loyal.

Opens in a new windowOpens an external siteOpens an external site in a new window